Pitchfork
March, 2001
Soft Boys
Underwater Moonlight
[Matador]
Rating: 8.5
by Sam Eccleston
If Rock 'n' Roll is, as it's always been hyped, the music of demonic teenage possession, of raving thugs and floozies possessed by illegal chemicals and their own lower extremities, then how come so much of it's about being uncomfortable? Few Rock songs have been written solely about the explosive, orgiastic joy of unbound pleasure. In fact, most deal with the stress, anxiety, and loathing that results from a lack of contentedness. And even songs that do focus on satisfaction generally mention the stress, anxiety, and loathing that results from too much of it. Boiled down to its essence, Rock 'n' Roll isn't about the wild pleasures of having a good time; it's about -- all together, now -- stress, anxiety, and loathing. Of course, with such a set of themes, the question becomes, "What are you supposed to do with this mess?"
No group has ever drawn a bead on this problem like The Soft Boys. Their definitive statement on the subject, Underwater Moonlight, taps into all the icky, oozing rage and fear that are necessary parts of adolescence, and, thus, the primary interests of its ideal audience. Thanks to both the roiling undercurrents of the music and the vague, paranoid rantings of singer-guitarist-songwriter Robyn Hitchcock, Underwater Moonlight sounds like a record by the nicest bar band in Freud's crazed Id. And as an added bonus, the album's not nearly as bleak and freaky as that description suggests. It's the darkest, heaviest Light Pop album anyone's ever made.
Freshly reissued by Matador, Underwater Moonlight presents the classic Soft Boys lineup -- Hitchcock, guitarist Kimberley Rew, bassist Matthew Seligman, and drummer Morris Windsor -- as the Band of the Avenging Dorks Who Can't Get Laid. Though the bonus set of unreleased demos from the period certainly sweetens the deal, the real show here is all in the original LP. Playing honeyed Pop songs with Punk fury, The Soft Boys ran through tracks like "I Wanna Destroy You" at breakneck pace, all the while dishing up Byrds-y harmonies and jangling guitars.
Hitchcock, who came off like a fey, scarf-wearing art student in the middle of a psychopathic killing spree, slurred angst-ridden, surreal images about sex and death and loathing and rot and ruin, and the joy of it all. Take, for example, the throbbing "I Got the Hots", the band's endearing take on wooing: "Said the dentures to the peach/Said the tide of filth to the bleach/Said the spike to the tomato/Said the curry to the corpse/'I got the hots for you'". Fun stuff, assuredly, but not exactly the make-out record of the year.
To somehow explain the weirdo menace of the production, liner-note writer David Fricke describes the circumstances of its creation. The album was made, apparently, under horribly stressful circumstances, with the band rehearsing in a humid little shack and recording under brutal low-tech conditions. Completely out of favor with the hipster record industry of the day, the band ended up initially releasing the thing themselves. That stress can be heard throughout the album: Rew knocks off genial Pop riffs that conceal sharpened fangs; Seligman thumbs his bass like he's auditioning for hell's Blues Rock band; and Hitchcock spits out stories about lamps and bugs and people who turn into animals. Anyone put off by the endearingly hippie-ish novelty act Hitchcock has become of late will be surprised to hear how genuinely monstrous he manages to sound on these sides.
Whereas a lot of New Wave and Punk reissues end up disappointing due to the datedness of older band's sounds, The Soft Boys seem more timeless than timed-out. Though they hardly sound of a piece with the Art Rock of the modern day (no 20-minute, drum-and-bass instrumentals here, kids), they don't really fit in anywhere else, either. Instead, their peculiar fusion of the sexy and the creepy exists in an odd little world of its own. Though there are certainly reference points shared with Glam, Punk and Folk Rock, the claustrophobic-but-bouncy attack Underwater Moonlight exhibits is another thing entirely. This is all that stress, anxiety, and loathing percolating under every great Rock song, and made to dance in front of the crowd.
In the end, of course, the power of The Soft Boys' music remains intact largely because of their strangeness. Because nobody's ever made a record that sounds exactly like this, or that even comes close to mining its depths of weird vigor, Underwater Moonlight ends up being that much more fascinating a listen. Turns out all that stress, anxiety, and loathing are good for something after all.
COPYRIGHT NOTICE